Case details

Court: ca10
Docket #: 13-4178
Case Name: Kitchen, et al v. Herbert, et al
PACER case #: 13-4178
Date filed: 2013-12-20
Date terminated: 2014-06-25
Nature of Suit: 3950 Constitutionality of State Statutes

Documents

Date Filed Document # Attachment # Short Description Long Description Upload date SHA1 hash
12/20/2013 01009176297 0 [10135373] Civil case docketed. Preliminary record filed. DATE RECEIVED: 12/20/2013. Docketing statement, transcript order form and entry of apperance due 01/03/2014 for Gary R. Herbert and John Swallow. Notice of appearance due on 01/03/2014 for Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood. [13-4178]
01009176297 1 NOA
01009176297 2 Judgment
01009176297 3 Memo & Order
01009176297 4 Docket
01009176297 5 General Docket Letter - Counsel - Civil
12/20/2013 01009176310 0 [10135378] Motion filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and John Swallow for stay of District Court's judgment entered December 20, 2013. Served on: 12/20/2013. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] SEP
12/21/2013 01009176319 0 [10135381] Notice of appearance submitted by Peggy A. Tomsic James E. Magleby Jennifer Fraser Parrish for Appellees Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood for court review. Certificate of Interested Parties: No. Served on 12/21/2013. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178] JEM
12/21/2013 01009176320 0 [10135382] Response filed by Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood to Appellants' Emergency Motion for Temporary Stay. Served on 12/21/2013. Manner of Service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] JFP
12/22/2013 01009176323 0 [10135385] Order filed by Judges Holmes and Bacharach denying motion for stay filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and John Swallow. See order for further details. Served on 12/22/2013. [13-4178] 2013-12-23 00:23:37 15c470da9b52fcb1527b04caf84b9d47afe405ee
12/23/2013 01009176332 0 [10135388] Motion filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and John Swallow for stay of memorandum decision and order dated December 20, 2013 pending resolution by the district court and 10th Circuit of motion(s) to stay pending appeal. Served on: 12/23/2013. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] SEP
12/23/2013 01009176343 0 [10135397] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. James E. Magleby, Ms. Jennifer Fraser Parrish and Ms. Peggy Ann Tomsic for Derek Kitchen, Moudi Sbeity, Karen Archer, Kate Call, Laurie Wood and Kody Partridge. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 12/21/2013. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178]
12/23/2013 01009176400 0 [10135424] Order filed by Judges Holmes and Bacharach denying appellants' renewed motion for stay filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and John Swallow. Served on 12/23/2013. (See the attachment for the full text of the order.) [13-4178] 2013-12-23 13:16:54 0e8d8260b3b977f234cffe65cfafd49b9b89405c
12/23/2013 01009176532 0 [10135498] Motion filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and John Swallow for stay of memorandum decision and order dated December 20, 2013 and temporary stay pending resolution of motion to stay. Served on: 12/23/2013. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] SEP
12/23/2013 01009176599 0 [10135524] Notice of intent to file opposition to emergency motion for stay filed by Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood. Served on 12/23/2013. Manner of Service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] --[Edited docket event and text to reflect title of pleading 12/23/2013 by SLS.] JFP
12/23/2013 01009176656 0 [10135553] Order filed by Judges Holmes and Bacharach: Following the district court's denial of their request for a stay pending appeal, Defendant-Appellants filed "Emergency Motion for Stay Pending Appeal and Temporary Stay Pending Resolution of Motion to Stay." Plaintiff-Appellees are ordered to file a response to these motions no later than 5:00 P.M. MST, today, 12/23/13. Served on 12/23/2013. [13-4178] 2013-12-23 15:22:50 5e912746071836dbaae7a1b54471c84078e250b2
12/23/2013 01009177089 0 [10135741] Response filed by Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood to Appellants' Emergency Motions to Stay. Served on 12/23/2013. Manner of Service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] PAT
01009177089 1 Main Document
01009177089 2 Ex A Order Denying Stay 12-23-13
01009177089 3 Ex B Transcript 12-23-13
12/24/2013 01009177122 0 [10135755] Supplement to motion for stay filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and John Swallow. Served on: 12/24/2013. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. --[Edited 12/24/2013 by GH to clarify pleading filed]. [13-4178] SEP
12/24/2013 01009177155 0 [10135767] Order filed by Judges Holmes and Bacharach denying motion for stay pending appeal and for temporary stay filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and John Swallow. This case will be heard on an expedited basis. See order for further details. Served on 12/24/2013. [13-4178] 2013-12-24 20:16:57 a5cfd0f90623207069ec0efa45baa7ecb3c66d3a
12/26/2013 01009178075 0 [10136213] Acknowledgment of transcript order filed by Mr. Stanford E. Purser for Mr. Gary R. Herbert and John Swallow. Transcript ordered: Summary Judgment Hearing held 12/4/13. Served on: 12/26/2013. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] SEP
12/27/2013 01009178350 0 [10136345] Transcript order form filed by Mr. Raymond Fenlon and Mr. Stanford E. Purser for Mr. Gary R. Herbert and John Swallow. Notice due that record is complete by 01/21/2014 for D. Mark Jones, Clerk of Court. [13-4178]
12/27/2013 01009178389 0 [10136364] Filed notice record is complete. Served on 12/27/2013. Appellant's brief and appendix due on 02/05/2014 for Gary R. Herbert and John Swallow. [13-4178]
12/30/2013 01009178943 0 [10136661] Order filed by Clerk of the Court (EAS): This matter is before the court to set an expedited briefing schedule. The schedule set here overrides the minute entry on the docket dated 12/27/13. Appellants' brief and appendix are due on 01/27/2014 for Gary R. Herbert and John Swallow. Appellees' response brief is due on 02/18/2014 for Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity, and Laurie Wood. Appellants' optional reply brief is due on or before 02/25/2014. Requests for extension of time are very strongly discouraged, and will be considered only under extraordinary circumstances. Served on 12/30/2013. [13-4178]
01/03/2014 01009180974 0 [10137974] Docketing statement filed by Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes. Served on 01/03/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] SEP
01/03/2014 01009181012 0 [10137986] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Philip S. Lott and Mr. Stanford E. Purser for Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: y. Served on 01/03/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178]
01/07/2014 01009182308 0 [10138730] Notice of appearance filed by Ralph E. Chamness and Darcy Marie Goddard for Not Party Sherrie Swensen. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 01/07/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
01/07/2014 01009182367 0 [10138753] Order of Supreme Court filed staying permanent injunction issued by the USDC Utah on 12/20/13 pending disposition of the appeal. [13-4178]
01/08/2014 01009182755 0 [10139000] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Shannon Price Minter and Ms. Kathryn Kendell for Laurie Wood, Moudi Sbeity, Kody Partridge, Derek Kitchen, Kate Call and Karen Archer. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 01/08/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178]
01/16/2014 01009186946 0 [10141390] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. David C. Codell for Laurie Wood, Moudi Sbeity, Kody Partridge, Derek Kitchen, Kate Call, and Karen Archer. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 01/15/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
01/17/2014 01009188274 0 [10142016] Motion filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes to extend time to file appellant/petitioner's brief until 02/06/2014. Served on: 01/17/2014. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] SEP
01/18/2014 01009188783 0 [10142241] Response filed by Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood to Defendants-Appellants' Motion for Extension of Time to File Opening Brief. Served on 01/18/2014. Manner of Service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] PAT
01/20/2014 01009188837 0 [10142261] Reply filed by Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes to Motion for Extension of Time to File Opening Brief. Served on 01/20/2014. Manner of Service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] SEP
01/21/2014 01009188944 0 [10142310] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Gene Schaerr for Sean Reyes and Mr. Gary R. Herbert. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 01/20/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
01/21/2014 01009189312 0 [10142479] Order filed by Clerk of the Court (EAS), at the direction of the court, granting as modified appellants' motion to extend the briefing schedule. Appellants' brief and appendix now due on 02/03/2014 for Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes. Appellees' brief now due 02/25/2014 for Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood. Appellants' optional reply brief now due 03/04/2014 for Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes. Served on 01/21/2014. [13-4178]
01/24/2014 01009191743 0 [10143720] Joint Notice of Consent to File Brief of Amicus Curiae filed by Appellants and Appellees. Served on 01/24/2014. Manner of Service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] --[Edited 01/24/2014 by SLS to change docket event and text to reflect title of pleading and add party filers.] GCS
01/27/2014 01009192682 0 [10144168] Notice of appearance filed by John J. Bursch for Sean Reyes and Gary R. Herbert. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 01/27/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
01/28/2014 01009193453 0 [10144545] Order filed by Clerk of the Court (EAS) upon consideration, and at the direction of the court, granting Sally Howe Smith's motion to expedite appeal filed in 14-5003. The directives in this order apply to 14-5003 and 14-5006. These cases will be assigned to the same panel considering 13-4178, but the appeals will brief separately and be set for argument separately. The amicus parties may file briefs jointly in all three cases as set forth. First brief on cross-appeal and appendix due 02/24/2014 for Sally Howe Smith. Second cross-appeal brief and any supplemental appendix due 03/17/2014. Third brief on cross-appeal due 04/01/2014. Fourth brief on cross-appeal due 04/07/2014. Requests for extension of time are discouraged. A copy of this order shall be forwarded to all counsel in 13-4178. Please see attached order for further details. Served on 01/28/2014. [14-5003, 14-5006, 13-4178]
01/28/2014 01009193690 0 [10144665] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Monte Neil Stewart for Mr. Sean Reyes and Mr. Gary R. Herbert. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 01/28/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
01/29/2014 01009194348 0 [10145009] Order filed by Clerk of the Court setting this case for oral argument on April 10, 2014 at 10:00 a.m. Served on 01/29/2014. [13-4178]
01/29/2014 01009194351 0 [10145010] Calendar notice sent to counsel. Arguments to be held on 04/10/2014 at 10:00 a.m. in Courtroom I of the Byron White United States Courthouse, Denver, CO. Counsel is required to go to http://www.ca10.uscourts.gov under the argument calendar tab to obtain an important notice regarding calendared cases and required forms. The calendar acknowledgment form must be completed and filed with the clerk via Electronic Case Filing within 10 days of today's date. [13-4178]
01/29/2014 01009194552 0 [10145109] Motion filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes to file an oversize brief 24000 words long. Served on: 01/29/2014. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] GCS
01/30/2014 01009194858 0 [10145315] Order filed by Clerk of the Court (EAS) granting appellants' motion to exceed word count in opening brief. Appellants may file an opening brief up to, but not greater than, 24,000 words in length. The deadline remains 02/03/2014. Served on 01/30/2014. [13-4178]
01/31/2014 01009195591 0 [10145679] Oral Argument Acknowledgment Form filed by Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood. Served on 01/31/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] PAT
01/31/2014 01009195826 0 [10145825] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Paul Benjamin Linton for Famiy Research Council. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 01/31/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
01/31/2014 01009195898 0 [10145860] Motion submitted by Douglas Wortham and Nicholas Nero, Lynn Beltran and Claudia O'Grady, Stanford Rovig and Charles Fluke for leave to file an intervenor brief. Served on: 01/31/2014 Manner of service: email. [13-4178] RAK 2014-02-01 00:08:18 4d6564c0698179565bd5f646a9f07e320b9b3549
02/03/2014 01009196029 0 [10145931] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Stephen Kent Ehat for The Center for Urban Renewal and Education, The Coalition of African-American Pastors USA and The Frederick Douglass Foundation, Inc. in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/01/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
01/31/2014 01009196242 0 [10146044] Motion to Intervene and Participate in Oral Argument filed by Movants Charles Fluke, Stanford Rovig, Claudia O'Grady, Lynn Beltran, Nicholas Nero and Douglas Wortham. Served on 01/31/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/03/2014 01009196253 0 [10146049] Order filed by Clerk of the Court - This matter is before the court on the "Proposed Intervenor Couples" opposed motion to intervene and to participate in oral argument. At the direction of the court, and upon its review, the motion is denied. Served on 02/03/2014. [13-4178] 2014-02-04 22:38:34 0d94c9c7f50ce201924eed9abdb2da4be0ec9880
02/03/2014 01009196784 0 [10146285] Appellant/Petitioner's brief filed by Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes. 7 paper copies to be provided to the court. Served on 02/03/2014 by email. Oral argument requested? Yes. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] GCS
01009196784 1 Main Document 2014-02-04 22:49:48 897cf8e961e36b8e0e717ddcf326573f32f32e17
01009196784 2 district court decision
01009196784 3 state law chart
02/03/2014 01009196789 0 [10146286] Certificate of service filed by Mr. Stanford E. Purser for Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes. Document served: Appellate Appendix. Served on 02/02/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] GCS
02/04/2014 01009196792 0 [10146287] Amicus Curiae brief submitted by AMICI CURIAE THE CENTER FOR URBAN RENEWAL AND EDUCATION, THE COALITION OF AFRICAN-AMERICAN PASTORS USA, AND THE FREDERICK DOUGLASS FOUNDATION, INC.. 7 paper copies to be provided to the court. Served on 02/04/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006] SKE
02/04/2014 01009197042 0 [10146488] Amici Curiae brief filed by The Center for Urban Renewal and Education, The Coalition of African-American Pastors USA and The Frederick Douglass Foundation, Inc. in 13-4178, 14-5003 and 14-5006. Original and 7 copies.. Served on 02/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006] 2014-02-04 22:37:27 16d62d5b9bfa5851bb8acefc8edc89b394300be0
02/04/2014 01009197161 0 [10146550] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. David Robert Upham for Professor David R. Upham as amicus curiae in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/05/2014 01009197445 0 [10146720] Admissions letter sent. Response date set to 03/07/2014 for David Robert Upham. [13-4178]
02/05/2014 01009197726 0 [10146899] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Richard D. White, Jr. for Ms. Helen M. Alvare in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/05/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/05/2014 01009197808 0 [10146942] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Lynn Dennis Wardle for Utah Counties in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/05/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/05/2014 01009197829 0 [10146972] Notice of appearance filed by Jaren E. Janghorbani and Roberta A. Kaplan for Douglas Wortham, Nicholas Nero, Lynn Beltran, Claudia O'Grady, Stanford Rovig, and Charles Fluke. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/05/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/05/2014 01009197910 0 [10147024] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Jacob Harris Hupart and Mr. Joshua Kaye for Douglas Wortham, Stanford Rovig, Claudia O'Grady, Nicholas Nero, Charles Fluke and Lynn Beltran in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/05/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/05/2014 01009197942 0 [10147038] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Alan B. Morrison for Douglas Wortham, Nicholas Nero, Lynn Beltran, Claudia O'Grady, Stanford Rovig and Charles Fluke. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/05/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/06/2014 01009198110 0 [10147141] Admissions letter sent. Response date set to 03/10/2014 for Jaren E. Janghorbani. [13-4178]
02/06/2014 01009198329 0 [10147280] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Thomas Molnar Fisher for State of Indiana and other amici states in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/06/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/06/2014 01009198401 0 [10147320] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. David C. Walker for Douglas W. Allen, Ph. D., David J. Eggebeen, Ph. D., Alan J. Hawkins, Ph. D., Byron R. Johnson, Ph. D., Catherine R. Pakaluk, Ph. D., Joseph Price, Ph. D. and Mark D. Regnerus, Ph. D. in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/06/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006] 2014-02-08 23:44:17 b54f451533c0ccf8000f21b0d49e043c7861505c
02/06/2014 01009198500 0 [10147404] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Family Research Council. 7 copies. Served on 02/06/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] 2014-02-16 23:31:33 c49338eaad0eaf8df78b7889e1d4cc69313e7bdd
02/07/2014 01009198938 0 [10147664] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Michael F. Smith for Sherif Girgis, Mr. Robert P. George and Mr. Ryan Anderson in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/07/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/07/2014 01009198960 0 [10147676] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Steven W. Fitschen, Esq. for Concerned Women of America. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/07/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/07/2014 01009199073 0 [10147777] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. William C. Duncan for The Sutherland Institute. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/07/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/07/2014 01009199230 0 [10147844] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Frank D. Mylar, Jr., Esq. for Russell Moore, Ph. D., American Leadership Fund, Douglas Ambrose, Ph. D., Herman Belz, Ph. D., Robert D. Benne, Ph. D., Allan C. Carlson, Ph. D., G.M. Curtis, Ph. D., Michael O. Emerson, Ph. D., Dr. Timothy George, Th. D., Harold James, Ph. D., Steven Justice, Ph. D., Robert C. Koons, Ph. D., Stanley Kurtz, Ph. D., Gerald R. McDermott, Ph. D., Robert Paquette, Ph. D., Paul A. Rahe, Ph. D., Michael A. Reynolds, Ph. D., Robert Louis Wilken, Ph. D., Christopher Wolfe, Ph. D. and Peter W. Wood, Ph. D. in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/07/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/07/2014 01009199233 0 [10147847] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Lawrence John Joseph for Eagle Forum Education & Legal Defense Fund. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/07/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/07/2014 01009199284 0 [10147899] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Kevin Trent Snider for Paul McHugh, M.D. in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/07/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006] --[Edited 02/07/2014 by SLS to indicate "n" for interested parties as parties named have already been disclosed.]
02/07/2014 01009199338 0 [10147922] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Alexander Dushku, R. Shawn Gunnarson and Mr. Justin W. Starr for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, National Association of Evangelicals, United States Confrerence of Catholic Bishops, The Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention and Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/07/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/07/2014 01009199459 0 [10147970] Oral Argument Acknowledgment Form filed by Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes. Served on 02/07/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] GCS
02/07/2014 01009199490 0 [10147992] Notice of appearance filed by Eric C. Rassbach for The Becket Fund for Religious Liberty in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/07/2014. Manner of Service: email.
02/07/2014 01009199496 0 [10147997] Notice of appearance filed by Dani Hartvigsen for Doug Mainwaring, Alana Newman, Robert Oscar Lopez and Janna Anderson in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/07/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/07/2014 01009199499 0 [10147999] Notice of appearance filed by Robert Theron Smith for Lowry Snow, LaVar Christensen, Kay McIff and Merrill Nelson in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/07/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
01009199504 0
01009199507 0
02/07/2014 01009199511 0 [10148008] Motion filed by Appellees Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood to file an oversize brief 24000 words long. Served on: 02/07/2014. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] PAT
02/10/2014 01009199556 0 [10148028] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Lynn Dennis Wardle for Utah Counties and Mr. Jason S. Carroll, Ph. D. in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/05/2014. Manner of Service: email.
02/10/2014 01009199565 0 [10148032] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Jennifer L. Bursch for Institute for Marriage and Public Policy in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/07/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009199739 0 [10148117] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Douglas W. Allen, Ph. D., David J. Eggebeen, Ph. D., Byron R. Johnson, Ph. D., Catherine R. Pakaluk, Ph. D., Joseph Price, Ph. D. and Mark D. Regnerus, Ph. D. in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies.. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009199851 0 [10148168] Order filed by Clerk of the Court (EAS) granting appellees' motion to exceed word count. Appellees may file a response brief up to, but not greater than, 24,000 words. The brief remains due 02/25/2014. Served on 02/10/2014. [13-4178]
02/10/2014 01009199885 0 [10148189] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Arthur Andrew Schulcz, Sr. for Parents and Friends of Ex-Gays & Gays in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009199924 0 [10148206] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Mr. Ryan Anderson, Mr. Robert P. George, and Sherif Girgis in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. 7 paper copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009199976 0 [10148229] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Ms. Helen M. Alvare in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. 7 copies.. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200026 0 [10148253] Amici Curiae brief filed by State of Alabama, State of Alaska, State of Arizona, State of Colorado, State of Idaho, State of Indiana, State of Montana, State of Nebraska, State of Oklahoma and State of South Carolina in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200105 0 [10148295] Admissions letter sent. Response date set to 03/12/2014 for Jennifer L. Bursch. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200139 0 [10148308] Admissions letter sent. Response date set to 03/12/2014 for Dani Hartvigsen. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200179 0 [10148325] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Douglas Ambrose, Ph. D., American Leadership Fund, Herman Belz, Ph. D., Robert D. Benne, Ph. D., Allan C. Carlson, Ph. D., G.M. Curtis, Ph. D., Michael O. Emerson, Ph. D., Timothy George, Harold James, Ph. D., Steven Justice, Ph. D., Robert C. Koons, Ph. D., Stanley Kurtz, Ph. D., Gerald R. McDermott, Ph. D., Russell Moore, Robert Paquette, Ph. D., Paul A. Rahe, Ph. D., Michael A. Reynolds, Ph. D., Robert Louis Wilken, Ph. D., Christopher Wolfe, Ph. D. and Peter W. Wood, Ph. D. in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. 7 paper copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200230 0 [10148349] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Mr. David R. Upham in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. 7 hard copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200251 0 [10148359] Amicus Curiae brief filed by The Sutherland Institute. 7 paper copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/10/2014 01009200277 0 [10148372] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Anthony R. Picarello, Jr. for United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, National Association of Evangelicals, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention, and Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. --[Edited 02/10/2014 by GH to correct party name order] [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200290 0 [10148376] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. D'Arcy Winston Straub in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200300 0 [10148389] Amicus Curiae brief filed by State of Michigan and the State of Kansas in 13-4178, 14-5003 and 14-5006. Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]--[Edited 03/05/2014 by AT - Pursuant to the court's 3/514 order the State of Kansas is added to this entry as an Amicus party.]
02/10/2014 01009200317 0 [10148395] Docketing statement filed by Ms. Susan G. Barton and Ms. Gay E. Phillips. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [14-5006, 14-5003, 13-4178] JEW
01009200317 1 Main Document
01009200317 2 Opinion and Order
01009200317 3 Judgment
02/10/2014 01009200322 0 [10148396] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Institute for Marriage and Public Policy. Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/10/2014 01009200334 0 [10148407] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. John C. Eastman for Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence and 27 Scholars of Federalism and Judicial Restraint (Larry Alexander, Ryan J. Barilleaux, Patrick McKinley Brennan, Robert Lowry Clinton, Robert Cochran, Lloyd Cohen, Thomas F. Farr, Matthew J. Franck, Gary D. Glenn, Frank Guliuzza, Mark David Hall, Laurie M. Johnson, Joseph M. Knippenberg, Ken Masugi, Robert F. Nagel, Walter Nicgorski, Charles Rice, Ralph A. Rossum, Jon D. Schaff, Nathan Schlueter, Timothy Samuel Shah, Steven Smith, R.J. Snell, David L. Tubbs, Bradley C.S. Watson, Micah J. Watson, Warner R. Winborne) in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200360 0 [10148419] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence and 27 Scholars of Federalism and Judicial Restraint in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. 7 copies.. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200364 0 [10148420] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Parents and Friends of Ex-Gays & Gays. 7 hard copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/10/2014 01009200370 0 [10148424] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Brett Gilbert Scharffs for Mr. Michael J. Perry, Mr. Daniel O. Conkle and Mr. Brett Gilbert Scharffs in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200382 0 [10148428] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Mr. Daniel O. Conkle, Mr. Michael J. Perry and Mr. Brett Gilbert Scharffs in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. 7 copies.. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200400 0 [10148434] Amici Curiae brief filed by Robert Oscar Lopez, Doug Mainwaring and Alana Newman in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] --[Edited 02/11/2014 by SLS to remove docket entry from 14-5003, 14-5006.]
02/11/2014 01009200501 0 [10148481] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Stephen M. Crampton and Ms. Mary Elizabeth McAlister for National Association of Research and Therapy of Homosexuality. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200515 0 [10148486] Amicus Curiae brief filed by United States Conference of Catholic Bishops; National Association of Evangelicals, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints; The Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention and Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. 7 copies.. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/11/2014 01009200525 0 [10148491] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. David Boyle. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/10/2014 01009200531 0 [10148493] Amicus Curiae brief filed by D'Arcy Winston Straub in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. 7 copies.. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/11/2014 01009200544 0 [10148500] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Anita Staver and Mr. Mathew D. Staver for Liberty Counsel, Inc. in 13-4178. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200551 0 [10148504] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Concerned Women of America. Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] --[Edited 02/11/2014 by SLS to remove docket entry from 14-5003, 14-5006.]
02/10/2014 01009200556 0 [10148507] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Liberty Counsel, Inc. in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200583 0 [10148517] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Becket Fund for Religious Liberty in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200601 0 [10148531] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Eagle Forum Education & Legal Defense Fund. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. --[Edited 02/12/2014 by GH to correct filing date]. [13-4178]
02/10/2014 01009200615 0 [10148539] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Paul McHugh, in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. --[Edited 02/12/2014 by GH to correct filing date]. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200635 0 [10148547] Amicus Curiae brief filed by National Association for Research and Therapy of Homosexuality in 13-4178, 14-5003 and 14-5006 Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200673 0 [10148569] Amici Curiae brief filed by Mr. Jason S. Carroll, Ph. D. and Alan J. Hawkins, Ph. D. Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/10/2014 01009200706 0 [10148587] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Eighty-One Utah State Legislators, LaVar Christensen, Kay McIff, Merrill Nelson, and Lowry Snow. 7 hard copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/10/2014 01009200721 0 [10148593] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Mr. David Boyle. 7 hard copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/10/2014 01009200743 0 [10148607] Amici Curiae brief filed by Utah Counties: Juab, Beaver, Box Elder, Cache, Emery, Garfield, Iron, Kane, Millard, Morgan, Sanpete, Sevier, Uintah, Utah, Wasatch and Washington. Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/11/2014 01009200766 0 [10148619] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Aaron Lindstrom for State of Michigan. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/11/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/12/2014 01009201548 0 [10149007] Admissions letter sent. Response date set to 03/14/2014 for Aaron Lindstrom. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/12/2014 01009201737 0 [10149098] Motion for leave to file an amicus brief filed by Movant Mr. Duane Morley Cox. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: US mail. [13-4178]
02/12/2014 01009201926 0 [10149169] Order filed by Clerk of the Court granting motion to become amicus by Duane Morley Cox. Served on 02/12/2014. [13-4178]
02/12/2014 01009201933 0 [10149171] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Mr. Duane Morley Cox. Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: US mail. [13-4178]
02/12/2014 01009201942 0 [10149174] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Duane Morley Cox. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/10/2014. Manner of Service: US mail. [13-4178]
02/14/2014 01009202797 0 [10149595] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Troy L. Booher and Mr. Clifford J. Rosky for Equality Utah and Utah Pride Center. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/14/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178]
02/18/2014 01009203385 0 [10149883] Admissions letter sent. Response date set to 03/20/2014 for Clifford J. Rosky. [13-4178]
02/18/2014 01009203541 0 [10149953] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Paul March Smith for American Psychological Association in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/18/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/25/2014 01009208139 0 [10152393] Appellee/Respondent's brief filed by Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood. 7 paper copies to be provided to the court. Served on: 02/25/2014. Manner of service: email. Oral argument requested? Yes. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] PAT
02/26/2014 01009208297 0 [10152496] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Lynn Beltran, Charles Fluke, Nicholas Nero, Claudia O'Grady, Stanford Rovig and Douglas Wortham in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/26/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/26/2014 01009208385 0 [10152574] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Sarah Elizabeth April and Ms. Kathryn R. DeBord for Family Equality Council. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/26/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
02/26/2014 01009208396 0 [10152578] Motion filed by Amicus Curiae Family Equality Council to waive requirement to redact minor children's names (with parental consent) in Amicus Brief. Served on: 02/26/2014. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] SEA
02/26/2014 01009208848 0 [10152813] Motion filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes to extend time to file a reply brief until 03/11/2014, to file an oversize brief 12000 words long. Served on: 02/26/2014. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] GCS
02/27/2014 01009209266 0 [10153054] Order filed by Clerk of the Court (EAS) denying amicus curiae Family Equality Council's motion for an order allowing the use of minors' names in its brief. Served on 02/27/2014. [13-4178]
02/27/2014 01009209273 0 [10153056] Order filed by Clerk of the Court (EAS) granting Appellants' motion to extend time to file reply brief and to exceed the word count for that brief. Appellants' reply brief due 03/11/2014. In addition, the appellants may exceed the word count for that brief by 5,000 words, resulting in a maximum of 12,000 words. Served on 02/27/2014. [13-4178]
02/27/2014 01009209614 0 [10153289] Supplemental authority filed by Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood. Served on 02/27/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] PAT
02/27/2014 01009209663 0 [10153312] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Carmine D. Boccuzzi, Jr. for American Sociological Association in 13-4178. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/27/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/28/2014 01009209784 0 [10153369] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Daniel McNeel Lane, Jr., Esq. for Mr. Peter Bardaglio, Ph. D., Ms. Norma Basch, Ms. Stephanie Coontz, Ms. Nancy Cott, Mr. Toby L. Ditz, Ms. Ariela R. Dubler, Ms. Laura F. Edwards, Ms. Michael Grossberg, Mr. Hendrik Hartog, Ms. Ellen Herman, Ms. Martha Hodes, Mr. Linda K. Kerber, Ms. Alice Kessler-Harris, Ms. Elaine Tyler May, Ms. Serena Mayeri, Mr. Steve Mintz, Ms. Elizabeth Pleck, Ms. Carole Shammas, Ms. Mary Shanley, Ms. Amy Dru Stanley and Barbara Welke in appeals 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/27/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/28/2014 01009209991 0 [10153459] Notice of appearance filed by Felicia H. Ellsworth, Mark C. Fleming, Leah M. Litman, Ms. Dina Bernick Mishra, Mr. Alan E. Schoenfeld and Mr. Paul Reinherz Wolfson for Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/28/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
02/28/2014 01009210002 0 [10153465] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Alliance for a Better Utah. Original and 7 copies. Served on 02/28/2014. Manner of Service: US mail, email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006] [Edited to add attachments-- Edited 03/03/2014 by NA]
03/03/2014 01009210406 0 [10153656] Amicus Curiae brief filed by American Military Partner Association and Outserve-SLDN. Original and 7 copies. Served on 03/03/2014. Manner of Service: US mail, email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/03/2014 01009210434 0 [10153667] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Meghan S. Bailey, Ms. Susan Baker Manning, Ms. Margaret Sheer, and Mr. Michael Louis Whitlock for Employers and Organizations Representing Employers. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 02/28/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
03/03/2014 01009210482 0 [10153691] Motion filed by Amici Curiae Lynn Beltran, Charles Fluke, Nicholas Nero, Claudia O'Grady, Stanford Rovig and Douglas Wortham for leave to allow amicus curiae to participate at oral argument. Served on: 03/03/2014. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] RAK
03/03/2014 01009210621 0 [10153773] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Constitutional Law Scholars in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies. Served on 03/03/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/03/2014 01009210686 0 [10153804] Amicus Curiae brief filed by American Sociological Association in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. 7 copies. Served on 03/03/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/03/2014 01009210737 0 [10153836] Order filed by the Clerk at the direction of the Court - denying Attorney motion for leave to allow amicus curiae to participate at oral argument filed by Amici Curiae Douglas Wortham, Nicholas Nero, Lynn Beltran, Claudia O'Grady, Stanford Rovig and Charles Fluke. Served on 03/03/2014. [13-4178]
03/03/2014 01009210927 0 [10153928] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Kenneth Lee Salazar for Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/03/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/03/2014 01009211092 0 [10153996] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. John M. Mejia and Leah Farrell for NAACP Salt Lake Branch & NAACP Tri State Conference of Idaho, Nevada and Utah, Hispanic National Bar Association, Cimarron Alliance, Asian Americans Advancing Justice-Chicago, Asian Americans Advancing Justice, Asian Americans Advancing Justice-Asian Law Caucus, Americans Advancing Justice-Los Angeles, American Civil Liberties Union of Utah Foundation, Inc., ACLU, API Equality-LA, ACLU of Utah, ACLU of Oklahoma and 9to5. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/03/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009211297 0 [10154091] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Nicole Susan Phillis and Mr. Jerome Cary Roth for Bay Area Lawyers for Individual Freedom, Austin LGBT Bar Association, Freedom to Marry, LGBT & Allied Lawyers of Utah Bar Association, Love Honor Cherish, Marriage Equality USA, Minnesota Lavender Bar Association, National Asian Pacific America Bar Association, New Mexico Lesbian and Gay Lawyers Association, The OUTLaws, QLaw - the GLBT Bar Association of Washington, Stonewall Bar Association of Georgia, Inc., Stonewall Bar Association of Michigan and Stonewall Law Association of Greater Houston in 13-4178. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/03/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009211305 0 [10154095] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Lauren Schmidt and Mr. John V. McDermott, Esq. for Employers and Organizations Representing Employers in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/03/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009211325 0 [10154105] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Gerard Vincent Bradley for Paul McHugh, M.D. in appeals 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: y(all of the parties listed were previously disclosed). Served on 03/03/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009211407 0 [10154140] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Jiyun Cameron Lee and Mr. Andrew John Davis for Parents, Families and Friends of Lesbians and Gays, Inc. in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/03/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009211650 0 [10154261] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Christy L. Anderson, Ms. Sarah Elizabeth April, Ms. Kathryn R. DeBord and Stephen D. Gurr for Family Equality Council, Colage, Voices for Utah Children and Children's Center of Salt Lake City. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
03/04/2014 01009211789 0 [10154344] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Elizabeth B. Wydra for Cato Institute and Constitutional Accountability Center in appeals 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009211801 0 [10154347] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Cato Institute and Constitutional Accountability Center in 13-4178, 14-5003, and14-5006. 7 copies. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009211849 0 [10154367] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Parents, Families and Friends of Lesbians and Gays, Inc. in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies.. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009211887 0 [10154387] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Emily Martin for National Women's Law Center, Women's Law Project, Brad Sears, Colorado Women's Bar Association, Equal Rights Advocates, Legal Momentum, Southwest Women's Law Center, Legal Voice, National Association of Women Lawyers, National Partnership for Women & Families, Devon Carbado, Sharon Dolovich, Ms. Nan D. Hunter, Christine A. Littleton, Nancy Polikoff, Vicki Schultz, Seana Shiffrin and Adam Winkler in 13-4178. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009211961 0 [10154428] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Peter Sacks for New York, District of Columbia, Maine, New Mexico, Massachusetts, California, Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Iowa, Maryland, New Hampshire, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Washington in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009211985 0 [10154436] Amicus Curiae brief filed by American Psychological Association and The Utah Psychological Association in 13-4178, 14-5003 and 14-5006. 7 copies. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212028 0 [10154458] Amicus Curiae brief filed by GLMA: Health Professionals Advancing LGBT Equality in 13-4178, 14-5003 and in 14-5006. Original and 7 copies. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212037 0 [10154462] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Nicholas M. O'Donnell for GLMA: Health Professionals Advancing LGBT Equality in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212077 0 [10154483] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Jeffrey S. Trachtman for Episcopal Diocese of Utah, et al. in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212098 0 [10154496] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Christopher Dowden Man for Outserve-SLDN and American Military Partner Association in 13-4178. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212105 0 [10154503] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Equality Utah and Utah Pride Center in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. 7 copies. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: US mail, email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212149 0 [10154533] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Nicole Susan Phillis and Mr. Jerome Cary Roth for Colorado Gay Lesbian Bisexual Transgender (GLBT) Bar Association in 13-4178. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212163 0 [10154543] Amicus Curiae brief filed by ACLU, Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, et al., in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. Original and 7 copies.. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]--[Edited 03/05/2014 by NA] [Edited to add attachment, per the court's order of 3/5/14-- Edited 03/05/2014 by NA]
03/04/2014 01009212220 0 [10154571] Motion filed by Amici Curiae ACLU, Leadership Conference et al., for Leave to File an Attachment in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212227 0 [10154575] Amicus Curiae brief filed by California, Connecticut, Delaware, District of Columbia, Illinois, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont and Washington in 13-4178. Original and 7 copies. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/05/2014 01009212234 0 [10154580] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Historians of Antigay Discrimination in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies.. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212281 0 [10154604] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Mr. Peter Bardaglio, Ph. D., Ms. Norma Basch, Ms. Stephanie Coontz, Ms. Nancy Cott, Mr. Toby L. Ditz, Ms. Ariela R. Dubler, Ms. Laura F. Edwards, Ms. Michael Grossberg, Mr. Hendrik Hartog, Ms. Ellen Herman, Ms. Martha Hodes, Mr. Linda K. Kerber, Ms. Alice Kessler-Harris, Ms. Elaine Tyler May, Ms. Serena Mayeri, Mr. Steve Mintz, Ms. Elizabeth Pleck, Ms. Carole Shammas, Ms. Mary Shanley, Ms. Amy Dru Stanley, and Barbara Welke in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. Original and 7 copies.. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212289 0 [10154607] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Episcopal Diocese of Utah, et al. in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. Original and 7 copies.. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212315 0 [10154623] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Rita F. Lin and Ms. Laura W. Weissbein for Family Law Professors. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
03/04/2014 01009212328 0 [10154625] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Family Law Professors. 7 copies. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
03/05/2014 01009212339 0 [10154632] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Jeffrey A. Chanay and Mr. Bryan Charles Clark for State of Kansas in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email.
03/05/2014 01009212351 0 [10154638] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Stacy A. Carpenter, Bennett L. Cohen, Esq., Mr. Jon R. Dedon and Mr. Sean Robert Gallagher for Western Republicans. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/05/2014 01009212370 0 [10154648] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Western Republicans in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies.. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/05/2014 01009212385 0 [10154654] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Kenneth D. Upton, Jr. for Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund, Inc. in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/05/2014 01009212388 0 [10154655] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund, Inc. in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies.. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/05/2014 01009212400 0 [10154661] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Bay Area Lawyers for Individual Freedom, Austin LGBT Bar Association, Colorado Gay Lesbian Bisexual Transgender (GLBT) Bar Association, Freedom to Marry, LGBT & Allied Lawyers of Utah Bar Association, Love Honor Cherish, Marriage Equality USA, Minnesota Lavender Bar Association, National Asian Pacific America Bar Association, New Mexico Lesbian and Gay Lawyers Association, QLaw - the GLBT Bar Association of Washington, Stonewall Bar Association of Georgia, Inc., Stonewall Bar Association of Michigan, Stonewall Law Association of Greater Houston and The OUTLaws in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies.. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006] [Edited to add errata to brief-- Edited 03/05/2014 by NA]
03/05/2014 01009212408 0 [10154671] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Camilla Taylor for Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund, Inc. in 13-4178. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212430 0 [10154681] Motion to join the brief of amicus curiae State of Michigan filed by State of Kansas in 13-4178. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/05/2014 01009212444 0 [10154696] Amicus Curiae brief filed by National Women's Law Center in 13-4178. Original and 7 copies. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: US mail, email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/05/2014 01009212454 0 [10154704] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Howard University School of Law Civil Rights Clinic in 13-4178. Original and 7 copies. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: US mail, email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212485 0 [10154729] Amici Curiae brief filed by 46 Employers and Organizations Representing Employers: American International Group, Inc., et al. Original and 7 copies. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]--[Edited 03/17/2014 by KLP to attach an errata sheet.]
03/04/2014 01009212490 0 [10154732] Amici Curiae brief filed by Family Law and Conflict of Laws Professors: Sarah Abramowicz, et al. Original and 7 copies. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
03/05/2014 01009212510 0 [10154745] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Americans United for Separation of Church and State, Anti-Defamation League, Bend the Arc: A Jewish Partnership for Justice, Central Conference of American Rabbis, Hadassah, The Women's Zionist Organization of America, Inc., Hindu American Foundation, Interfaith Alliance Foundation, Interfaith Alliance of Colorado, Japanese American Citizens League, Jewish Social Policy Action Network, Keshet, Metropolitan Community Churches, More Light Presbyterians, National Counsel of Jewish Women, Nehirim, People for the American Way Foundation, Presbyterian Welcome, Reconcilingworks: Lutherans for Full Participation, Sikh American Legal Defense and Education Fund, Society for Humanistic Judaism, South Asian Americans Leading Together, T'Ruah: The Rabbinic call for Human Rights, Women of Reform Judaism and Women's League for Conservative Judaism. Original and 7 copies.. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
03/04/2014 01009212535 0 [10154758] Amici Curiae brief filed by Children's Center of Salt Lake City, Colage, Family Equality Council and Voices for Utah Children. Original and 7 copies. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178]
03/05/2014 01009212552 0 [10154765] Second supplemental notice of appearance filed by Mr. Nicole Susan Phillis and Mr. Jerome Cary Roth for Bar Association of San Francisco in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/05/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/04/2014 01009212563 0 [10154771] Amicus Curiae brief filed by Gay & Lesbian Advocates & Defenders in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. Original and 7 copies.. Served on 03/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/05/2014 01009212706 0 [10154835] Errata sheet filed by Mr. Jerome Cary Roth for Bay Area Lawyers for Individual Freedom, Austin LGBT Bar Association, Freedom to Marry, LGBT & Allied Lawyers of Utah Bar Association, Love Honor Cherish, Marriage Equality USA, Minnesota Lavender Bar Association, National Asian Pacific America Bar Association, New Mexico Lesbian and Gay Lawyers Association, The OUTLaws, QLaw - the GLBT Bar Association of Washington, Stonewall Bar Association of Georgia, Inc., Stonewall Bar Association of Michigan, Stonewall Law Association of Greater Houston, Colorado Gay Lesbian Bisexual Transgender (GLBT) Bar Association and Bar Association of San Francisco in 13-4178, Oklahoma City University School of Law OutLaws and University of Oklahoma College of Law Legal Group for Building Tolerance and Acceptance. Original and 7 copies. Served on 03/05/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006] NSP
03/05/2014 01009212783 0 [10154875] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Nicole Susan Phillis for and Mr. Jerome Cary Roth for Oklahoma City University School of Law OutLaws and University of Oklahoma College of Law Legal Group for Building Tolerance and Acceptance in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/05/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/05/2014 01009212842 0 [10154922] Order filed by Clerk of the Court (EAS) at the direction of the court, the motion of the State of Kansas to join the amicus brief filed by the State of Michigan on 2/10/14. The State of Kansas shall be added as an amicus part on that brief. Served on 03/05/2014. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006] 2014-03-23 16:30:47 fd7183d6c6503b2f77d32dd7936d5c3dd8c29581
03/05/2014 01009212860 0 [10154933] Order filed by Clerk of the Court (EAS) This matter is before the court on the motion of the Amici Curiae 22 Bar Associations, Public-Interest Organizations and Legal Service Organizations for Leave to File an Attachment. At the direction of the court, the motion is granted. The attachment shall be shown as filed with the amicus brief. Served on 03/05/2014. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006] 2014-03-23 16:35:39 7f633491e5faca750c12a77dc768331f5a0f10ec
03/06/2014 01009213439 0 [10155340] Motion filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes to extend time to file a reply brief until 03/14/2014. Served on: 03/06/2014. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] GCS
03/06/2014 01009213509 0 [10155381] Order filed by Clerk of the Court This matter is before the court on the appellants' unopposed motion for a three day extension of time to file the reply brief. Upon consideration, and at the direction of the court the motion is granted. The new filing dated for the reply brief is 03/14/2014. Served on 03/06/2014. [13-4178]
03/10/2014 01009214339 0 [10155827] Order filed by Clerk of the Court outlining the protocol to be followed for the oral argument scheduled for Thursday, April 10, 2014. The order details Courtroom Location and Seating; Identification; Prohibition on Broadcasting, Recording, and Photography; Use of Laptops and Tablets in Courtrooms; Cell Phones; Overflow Audio and Video Feed Access; Media and Public Areas; and Digital Recording. Served on 03/10/2014. [13-4178]
03/11/2014 01009215776 0 [10156508] Motion filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes to file an oversize brief 20000 words long. Served on: 03/11/2014. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] GCS
03/12/2014 01009216051 0 [10156661] Order filed by Clerk of the Court This matter is before the court on the appellants' unopposed request to use an additional 8,000 words in their reply brief. Upon consideration, and at the direction of the court, the motion is granted. The appellants may file a reply brief up to 20,000 words in length. The brief remains due March 14, 2014. Served on 03/12/2014. [13-4178]
03/12/2014 01009216331 0 [10156796] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Lori Ann Alvino McGill for Constitutional Law Scholars in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/12/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/14/2014 01009218227 0 [10157832] Appellant/Petitioner's reply brief filed by Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes. 7 paper copies to be provided to the court. Served on 03/14/2014. Manner of Service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] GCS
03/16/2014 01009218233 0 [10157834] Supplemental authority filed by Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood. Served on 03/16/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] PAT
03/20/2014 01009220468 0 [10158939] Deficiency notice issued. Type of deficiency: no entry of appearance filed. Notice of appearance due on 03/27/2014 for Historians of Antigay Discrimination [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/20/2014 01009220500 0 [10158954] Deficiency notice issued. Type of deficiency: Entry of appearance not filed. Notice of appearance due on 03/27/2014 for Anti-Defamation League and Howard University School of Law Civil Rights Clinic. [13-4178]
03/20/2014 01009220574 0 [10158994] Notice of appearance filed by Ms. Catherine Emily Stetson for Historians of Antigay Discrimination in 13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: y. Served on 03/20/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/20/2014 01009220934 0 [10159143] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. Rocky Chiu-feng Tsai for People for the American Way Foundation, Anti-Defamation League, National Council of Jewish Women, Americans United for Separation of Church and State, Women of Reform Judaism, Hindu American Foundation, Hadassah, The Women's Zionist Organization of America, Inc., Interfaith Alliance Foundation, Central Conference of American Rabbis, Bend the Arc: A Jewish Partnership for Justice, Interfaith Alliance of Colorado, Japanese American Citizens League, Jewish Social Policy Action Network, Keshet, Metropolitan Community Churches, More Light Presbyterians, Nehirim, Presbyterian Welcome, Reconcilingworks: Lutherans for Full Participation, Religious Institute, Inc., Sikh American Legal Defense and Education Fund, Society for Humanistic Judaism, South Asian Americans Leading Together, T'Ruah: The Rabbinic call for Human Rights and Women's League for Conservative Judaism. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/20/2014. Manner of Service: email [13-4178]
03/20/2014 01009220990 0 [10159175] Notice of appearance filed by Mr. David Scott Flugman for Howard University School of Law Civil Rights Clinic in 13-4178, 14-5003, and 14-5006. CERT. OF INTERESTED PARTIES: n. Served on 03/20/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003, 14-5006]
03/21/2014 01009221272 0 [10159310] Admissions letter sent. Response date set to 04/21/2014 for Rocky Chiu-feng Tsai. [13-4178]
03/21/2014 01009221603 0 [10159478] Motion to present oral argument filed by Amicus Curiae Mr. Duane Morley Cox. Served on 03/17/2014. Manner of Service: US mail. [13-4178]
03/24/2014 01009221915 0 [10159641] Order filed by Clerk of the Court (EAS) This matter is before the court on Mr. Duane Morely Cox's Motion for Leave to Participate in Oral Arguments in Support of Utah's Constitutional Amendment No. 3. Upon consideration, and at the specific direction of the court, the motion is denied. Served on 03/24/2014. [13-4178]
03/24/2014 01009222047 0 [10159723] Supplemental authority filed by Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood. Served on 03/24/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] PAT
03/27/2014 01009224635 0 [10161176] Errata sheet filed by Mr. Stanford E. Purser for Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes in 13-4178. Original and 7 copies. Served on 03/27/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178, 14-5003] SEP
03/27/2014 01009224663 0 [10161186] Motion to reconsider filed by Amicus Curiae Mr. Duane Morley Cox. Served on 03/25/2014. Manner of Service: US mail. [13-4178]
03/28/2014 01009225408 0 [10161542] Order filed by Clerk of the Court (EAS) - At the direction of the court, order denying motion to reconsider filed by Amicus Curiae Mr. Duane Morley Cox. Served on 03/28/2014. [13-4178]
04/04/2014 01009228966 0 [10163567] Motion filed by Appellants Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes to enlarge time for oral argument. Served on: 04/04/2014. Manner of service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] GCS
04/04/2014 01009229044 0 [10163610] Order filed by Clerk of the Court - Response by Plantiffs-Appellees to Defendants-Appellants' Motion to Extend Oral Argument due today, April 4, 2014 by 5:00 P.M. mountain time. Served on 04/04/2014. [13-4178]
04/04/2014 01009229242 0 [10163810] Response filed by Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood to Defendants'-Appellants' Motion to Extend Oral Arguments. Served on 04/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] PAT
04/04/2014 01009229366 0 [10163872] Response filed by Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes to Rule 28(j) letter citing DeBoer v. Snyder. Served on 04/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] GCS
04/04/2014 01009229369 0 [10163874] Response filed by Mr. Gary R. Herbert and Sean Reyes to Rule 28(j) letter citing Tanco v. Haslam. Served on 04/04/2014. Manner of Service: email. This pleading complies with all required (privacy, paper copy and virus) certifications: Yes. [13-4178] --[Edited to change docket event and text (from reply to response) 04/07/2014 by SLS.] GCS
04/07/2014 01009229701 0 [10164130] Order filed by Kelly, Lucero and Holmes granting motion to enlarge time for argument. Each side will have 30 minutes to present oral argument. Served on 04/07/2014. [13-4178]
2014-05-21 01009253427 0 [10178034] Supplemental authority filed by Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood. Served on 05/21/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] PAT
2014-05-23 01009254416 0 [10178560] Motion to reconsider [10172701-2] order denying motion to intervene as plaintiff filed by Movant Chris Sevier. (The document is entitled: Motion to Intervene as Plaintiff.) Served on 05/20/2014. Manner of Service: email, US mail. [13-4178]
2014-05-23 01009254585 0 [10178630] Order filed by Judges Kelly, Lucero and Holmes (EAS) construing Chris Sevier's motion to intervene as plaintiff as a motion for reconsideration. Upon consideration, the request for reconsideration is denied. Served on 05/23/2014. Served on 05/23/2014. [13-4178]
2014-06-12 01009263424 0 [10183307] Supplemental authority filed by Karen Archer, Kate Call, Derek Kitchen, Kody Partridge, Moudi Sbeity and Laurie Wood. Served on 06/12/2014. Manner of Service: email. [13-4178] PAT
2014-06-25 01009269273 0 [10186299] Affirmed. Terminated on the merits after oral hearing. Written, signed, published. Judges Kelly (concurring in part and dissenting in part), Lucero (authoring), and Holmes. The mandate is stayed. [13-4178] --[Edited 06/25/2014 by SLS to correct typo on page 4.]
2014-06-25 01009269278 0 [10186301] Judgment for opinion filed. [13-4178]
2014-08-06 01009291031 0 [10196616] Petition for writ of certiorari filed by Gary R. Herbert on 08/05/2014. Supreme Court Number 14-124. [13-4178]
2014-10-06 01009321265 0 [10212545] Order filed by Judges Kelly, Lucero and Holmes - On this date, the United States Supreme Court denied certiorari review in this matter. Consequently, the stay of the mandate directed in our decision dated 6/25/14 is lifted, and the mandate shall issue forthwith. A copy of this order shall stand as the mandate of this court. Served on 10/06/2014. [13-4178] 2014-10-06 12:47:20 2e9b94e5d33d304d586bae0c1a040780b231529b